The I-864 (I-485) Request for Evidence (RFE): What to do when you receive it

American Immigration Lawyers Association Logo

The I-864 Affidavit of Support is a required document for most Adjustment of Status Filings, especially family-based filings such as a filing for an Immigrant Spouse, Child, or Parent. The I-864 assesses the Financial Capabilities of the Petitioner, and determines Sponsorship Eligibility.

Now, if you are receiving the RFE or Request for Evidence for the I-864 (The USCIS Notice states the I-485 needs the I-864), one of four possibilities probably occurred:

What Determines whether someone has sufficient income?

The I-864P provides the Federal Poverty Level Guidelines. The Petitioner has to overcome both of the following to avoid receiving an RFE:

  1. Annual Income (Established by the past 12 months of paystubs from the same employment)
  2. Adjusted Gross Income – AGI (the taxed income in the 1040 Tax Return)

Many times someone meets the annual income, but their AGI is below the I-864P. Again, both figures must be above the I-864P.

You can make $1,000,000 a year, but if you have an AGI of $5000, USCIS would question your financial ability to sponsor an immigrant family member.

What if my AGI is too Low, but my Annual Income is Sufficient?

You have two options.

First, you can attach assets to the I-864. More information can be found here: I-864 Asset Calculations

Second, you can show USCIS the annual income overcomes the I-864P, and that the next tax years AGI will overcome the I-864P. How to do this? You can provide:

What if my income is insufficient in both annual income and AGI?

A Co-sponsor would be required if assets cannot help you overcome the I-864P.

More information on Joint Sponsors found here:

Should I provide IRS Form 1040 or the IRS Tax Return Transcript?

Our office recommends providing both, the 1040 and IRS Tax return Transcript. Guidance can be found here:

What if My Income or my Co-sponsor’s Income contains non-taxable VA Disability?

Our office has more information here:

Related Blog Posts:

Disclaimer: This Blog is made available by the lawyer or law firm publisher for educational purposes only as well as to give you general information and a general understanding of the law, not to provide specific legal advice. By using this blog site you understand that there is no attorney-client relationship between you and the Blog/Web Site publisher. The Blog should not be used as a substitute for competent legal advice from a licensed professional attorney in your state.

US Citizen's Guide to the Immigrant Visa Process for a Spouse or Fiance in Kuwait City

By Franchesco Fickey Martinez • 31 Jul, 2024

This Blog post will cover what a US Citizen needs to know about the Immigration process for a Spouse or Fiance in Kuwait. Based on our law firm experience, Kuwait filing have an even mixture of the Spouse of Fiance being (1) Kuwait Citizen, (2) Philippine Citizen, or (3) a citizen of another country. With this in mind, we will try to cover the document requirements and process more broadly. Additionally, Numerous Active Duty Service Members and DOD Contractors appear to be stationed in Kuwait, at Camp Arifjan (AJ). Some common topics can be seen here:

Philippine CENOMAR: Certificate of No Marriage

By Franchesco Fickey Martinez • 29 Jul, 2024

The CENOMAR or Certificate of No Marriage is a mandatory document for Philippine Citizens in need of either a Fiance Visa, Spousal Visa, or another Green Card Visa. The CENOMAR must be issued by the PSA or Philippine Statistics Authority (NSO is no longer acceptable). The PSA is the primary ¢tral authority that validates […] The post Philippine CENOMAR: Certificate of No Marriage appeared first on Fickey Martinez Law Firm.

Philippines: NBI Police Clearance

By Franchesco Fickey Martinez • 29 Jul, 2024

The NBI Police Clearance is very similar to the FBI Fingerprint Check you would find in the United States. The NBI Clearance is issued by the National Bureau of Investigation (NBI). The document is the color Blue and annotated multi-purpose clearance. Procedure for Obtaining: Applicants who prefer to secure the certificate personally must proceed to […] The post Philippines: NBI Police Clearance appeared first on Fickey Martinez Law Firm.

PSA Philippine Birth Certificate

By Franchesco Fickey Martinez • 29 Jul, 2024

The Philippine Birth Certificate must be from the PSA, and not the NSO. The Birth Certificate can be one or two pages long and is a yellow/green color. Applications to order a Birth Certificate can be made in person by the individual or by his/her representative at Census Serbilis Centers. Documents applied at the East […] The post PSA Philippine Birth Certificate appeared first on Fickey Martinez Law Firm.

What does a USCIS Receipt Number (MSC, LIN, SRC, EAC, WAC, IOE) Mean?

By Franchesco Fickey Martinez • 29 Jul, 2024

[Leer Publicación en español] [Ler Post em Português] A USCIS Receipt Number is very similar to tracking a package on Amazon. The Receipt Number, better called a tracking number, allows a recipient to track a filing online, over the phone, or in person at an INFOPASS. Now, let’s dive deeper. The Receipt Number can be […] The post What does a USCIS Receipt Number (MSC, LIN, SRC, EAC, WAC, IOE) Mean? appeared first on Fickey Martinez Law Firm.

Canadian Long-Form Birth Certificate for US Immigration

By Franchesco Fickey Martinez • 28 Jul, 2024

USCIS, NVC, and DOS only accept the Long-Form Canadian Birth Certificates. This post will display the difference in Birth Certificates as it relates to US Immigration filings. What are the Basic Formats? There are a few basic formats for Birth Records across Canada: The “small” or “short form” certificate is a computer-printed, limited extract of […] The post Canadian Long-Form Birth Certificate for US Immigration appeared first on Fickey Martinez Law Firm.

US Citizen’s Guide to US Immigration of a Canadian Spouse or Fiance

By Franchesco Fickey Martinez • 28 Jul, 2024

This post will discuss two types of Immigrant Visas available for a Canadian Spouse or Fiance: CR-1/IR-1 Spousal (Immigrant) Visa K-1 Fiance (Immigrant) Visa Additionally, the Adjustment of Status filing option will be discussed. What US Consulate in Canada can you receive an Immigrant Visa? Montreal. The only US Consulate that processes Immigrant Visas in […] The post US Citizen’s Guide to US Immigration of a Canadian Spouse or Fiance appeared first on Fickey Martinez Law Firm.

Canadian Divorce Decree for US Immigration Purposes

By Franchesco Fickey Martinez • 28 Jul, 2024

The US Government accepts two versions of a Canadian Divorce Decree: Original / Court-Certified copy of the Final Divorce Decree from the Court where the divorce took place Form 36B: Certificate of Divorce (Example found here: http://ontariocourtforms.on.ca/static/media/uploads/courtforms/family/36b/flr-36b-e.pdf) A good practice is to acquire and provide BOTH versions of the Divorce Decree, as the Certified Court […] The post Canadian Divorce Decree for US Immigration Purposes appeared first on Fickey Martinez Law Firm.

US Citizen’s Guide to Immigrating a Brazilian Spouse or Fiance

By Franchesco Fickey Martinez • 27 Jul, 2024

Our office has two guides for a significant other from Brazil, whether it be for a spouse or a fiance. Please select the guide that is ideal for your relationship status: Brazilian Spouse US Citizen’s Guide to Immigrating a Brazilian Spouse Brazilian Fiance K-1 Fiance Visa: Brazilian Fiance The post US Citizen’s Guide to Immigrating a Brazilian Spouse or Fiance appeared first on Fickey Martinez Law Firm.

US Citizen’s Guide to Immigrating a Brazilian Spouse

By Franchesco Fickey Martinez • 27 Jul, 2024

This post will discuss the Spousal Immigrant Visas available for a Brazilian Spouse, know as the: CR-1 Conditional Immediate Relative based on a marriage less than 2 years old IR-1 Immediate Relative based on a marriage more than 2 years old This Post will not cover the K-3 Immigrant Visa, due to the low approval […] The post US Citizen’s Guide to Immigrating a Brazilian Spouse appeared first on Fickey Martinez Law Firm.